ON THE WIRE
NOW LIVE — Verdicts, rankings, and community scoresBG3 scores a perfect 10 — our first S+ gradeGTA VI drops November 2026 — on our radarMarvel’s Wolverine · SEP 15 — verdict incomingCommunity board waiting for votes — be the first10 rankings live — Best Games Like Hades, BG3, Elden Ring and moreBREAKINGSony Is Being Sued for $457 Million for Killing the DiscHellblade. Psychonauts. State of Decay. Xbox Was Closing These Studios. They Fought Back and Won.GTA 6 Will Probably Be the Best Game in Years. It's Also Setting the Worst Precedents.PlayStation Is Killing the Disc. All New Games Go Digital-Only from January 2028.The List Is Growing: Undead Labs Is Now the Fourth Xbox Studio Facing the AxeBungie Announces Layoffs — Destiny 2 Is Done and the Studio Reorganizes Around MarathonLISTBest Games Like HadesLISTBest Games Like FortniteLISTBest Games Like Stardew ValleyNOW LIVE — Verdicts, rankings, and community scoresBG3 scores a perfect 10 — our first S+ gradeGTA VI drops November 2026 — on our radarMarvel’s Wolverine · SEP 15 — verdict incomingCommunity board waiting for votes — be the first10 rankings live — Best Games Like Hades, BG3, Elden Ring and moreBREAKINGSony Is Being Sued for $457 Million for Killing the DiscHellblade. Psychonauts. State of Decay. Xbox Was Closing These Studios. They Fought Back and Won.GTA 6 Will Probably Be the Best Game in Years. It's Also Setting the Worst Precedents.PlayStation Is Killing the Disc. All New Games Go Digital-Only from January 2028.The List Is Growing: Undead Labs Is Now the Fourth Xbox Studio Facing the AxeBungie Announces Layoffs — Destiny 2 Is Done and the Studio Reorganizes Around MarathonLISTBest Games Like HadesLISTBest Games Like FortniteLISTBest Games Like Stardew Valley
REVIEWNarrative · Medieval Mystery

Pentiment

A medieval murder mystery painted like an illuminated manuscript — Obsidian's most daring game.

Pentiment
PCXSX

YOU’LL LOVE IT IF…

  • History enthusiasts and literary readers who play games
  • Players who loved Disco Elysium's pure narrative focus
  • Anyone wanting something genuinely unlike anything else on the market

SKIP IT IF…

  • Action-focused players
  • Those wanting combat, conventional RPG systems, or spectacle

Score breakdown

Art Direction10.0
Writing9.5
Mystery Design8.5
Replayability8.5
Value9.5

+ THE GOOD

  • Art style is completely unique — every screen looks like a painting
  • Murder mystery genuinely surprises at multiple turns
  • Replays reveal new truths — designed for multiple playthroughs
  • Deeply researched historical setting that never feels like homework

− THE BAD

  • Extremely niche — zero appeal for action or open-world fans
  • Final act loses some of the mystery's momentum
BUYNEXT SAVE POINT

Final word: Buy it.

Pentiment earns a 9.0/10 (A+) and a BUY. Best on PC. Worth your time? YES.

Verdicts are ours alone — never paid for, never previewed by publishers.
MORE VERDICTS

Fresh off the board

// NEWSLETTER

NO HYPE.
JUST GAMES.

Verdict drops, ranking updates, and the gaming news that actually matters — straight to your inbox. No sponsors. No fluff. Unsubscribe anytime.

YOUR EMAIL

No spam. No paid placements. Unsubscribe with one click.

Getting a security error? Reload the page and wait for the Cloudflare checkbox to appear before submitting.